• Home
  • All Videos
  • About
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Home
  • All Videos
  • About
  • Contact Us
All Videos
Get videos via whatsapp
Join Options

Menu

  • Home
  • All Videos
  • About
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Home
  • All Videos
  • About
  • Contact Us
All Videos

Get Our Newest Videos Via Email

Playing Monopoly (or Fake Money Games) on Shabbos + Scrabble Regular/Deluxe Edition [#85]

2 years ago
0
Share
WhatsApp Linked In E-mail
    Rabbi Binyamin Ghermezian Rabbi Binyamin Ghermezian
    Subscriber
    Click To Download/Print Text Version (Please Take A Copy To Shul etc.)

    (Scroll down ???? for video transcription text)

    Download Video

    Standard Quality Video
    HD Quality Video

    Listen/Download Audio

    Press "Play" Button To Listen To Audio
    Press "Play" Button To Listen To Audio
    Press "Play" Button To Listen To Audio
    {{svg_share_icon}}
    Download Audio

    Video Transcription

    Today's question is regarding playing certain board games on Shabbos. We're in the summer months, where Shabbos day is longer, and people are trying to find ways to occupy themselves through the end of Shabbos. The question has come up of whether playing certain games are halachically permissible or not on Shabbos.

                 Mainly, we are speaking about the game of Monopoly, or other similar games, where people are using fake money. The question is, we know you're not allowed to do business on Shabbos, so are you allowed to play Monopoly, which mimics business transactions, with buying and selling houses and stuff like that, and fake money is transferred? Is that allowed on Shabbos?

                 As well, we are going to speak about another well-known and played board game, Scrabble, and Scrabble Deluxe edition, once we’re on the topic of board games.

                 Before we bring the answer, there are two additional concerns with playing board games which must be addressed:

                 The first thing is that there's an aspect of borer, separating pieces, of which a person has to be very careful. Even for games which are permissible, a person must be aware that, when they start the game, they're allowed to take the pieces that they need, if they're going to play right away; however, when the game is over, you're not allowed to separate the pieces because that's not for immediate use. So, at the end of the game, a person has to just put all the pieces away and be done with it until after Shabbos.

                 The point that must be made, is that we're talking about games being played where there's no prizes awarded. If these games are attached to an actual prize of money, or food, or something like that, then it would be forbiddento be done on Shabbos (even if the actual game itself is permissible on its own [without the prizes]).

                 Getting to Monopoly, the halacha is, according to Rav Scheinberg, even though the game mimics business practices and business transactions, it is technically permitted and it would be allowed. He did add that it is not in the spirit of Shabbos to be playing Monopoly on Shabbos. The same was said by the Ohr Le'Tzion, Chacham Ben Zion Abba Shaul as well as Rav Simcha Bunim Cohen. They all say that it's allowed, though it's not in the spirit of Shabbos, and should therefore be limited, especially by adults. If children want to play these games, you should not force them to stop.

                 That is the halacha for Monopoly. Once we are already speaking about board games, there is another board game, Scrabble, which is also discussed by the Poskim if it is a problem of kesiva, writing on Shabbos. There are two parts to the question. One is about actually forming letters and words. There is also a separate problem of keeping track of scores, which may cause a person to write on Shabbos.

                 The halacha is as follows: Regarding the first issue of being considered that you are writing on Shabbos, the Poskim say that it’s not applicable by Scrabble and is not considered writing on Shabbos. However, when it comes to the 2nd aspect above (that people may come to write (their score) on Shabbos, some Poskim say that it is indeed a problem and therefore do not allow the play of Scrabble (all editions) on Shabbos.

                 The question about Scrabble regular edition, with a completely flat un-grooved board, was brought to Rav Scheinberg  who said that even though there are those Poskim who say Scrabble is not allowed to be played, still, it is okay to play Scrabble on Shabbos. However, a person should be extra careful and vigilant to not come to write down anything on Shabbos.

    Many people use a book with a napkin to keep track of their scores according to page number.

                 The question was also asked about the Deluxe Scrabble or “travel” Scrabble editions, where each piece is set in position by a border. Putting the pieces into these settings could be more of a problem of kesiva. Rav Yisroel Pinchos Bodner, the author of the Sefer Halachos of Muktza, (who is also the author of Halachos of Other People's Money which we have quoted from in many other MoneyHalacha videos, actually showed a Deluxe Scrabble board to Rav Moshe Feinstein. Rav Moshe Feinstein said that the Deluxe edition of Scrabble would not be allowed to be played with on Shabbos because of the locking pieces.

                 In summary, Monopoly, would be allowed to be played on Shabbos but the Gedolim have noted that it's not in the spirit of Shabbos to be doing so, especially for those over Bar/Bat Mitzva. With regards to Scrabble, Rav Scheinberg said that the regular edition game (with flat board) may be played, but with regards to Deluxe Scrabble, or Travel Scrabble, where the pieces are set in place, R’ Moshe Feinstein said that it would not be allowed to be played on Shabbos.***

    __________________________________________________________________________________                                            

    ***Please note that these halachos are intended to inform and educate the reader/listener in general. For any specific questions which arise, it is recommended to speak over the exact case with a competent halachic authority in order to assess the halacha accordingly as any small change will greatly affect the final halacha. You can send your questions in to us as well by replying via WhatsApp to our halacha Q & A number on the group, sending an email to [email protected], or via our contact page at MoneyHalacha.com/contact-us

    __________________________________________________________________________________

    Transcription Provided By:

    jewishtranscription.com                                                                           [email protected]

    Category: Shabbat and YomTov/Chol HaMoed At Home & The Office
    Previous Post

    Using Office Equipment & Supplies for Personal/Family Use And Making Personal Phone Calls During Work Hours [#84]

    Next Post

    Can You “Steal” Someone’s Sleep By Waking Them Up? – Gezel Sheina [#86]

    Related Posts

    Can You Use A Switched Coat, Hat, or Similar Item?
    Stealing & Damages

    Can You Use A Switched Coat, Hat, or Similar Item? [#96]

    November 20, 2021
    Can You Pressure Someone to Sell You an Item or Give You a Gift? [#94]
    At Home & The Office

    Can You Pressure Someone to Sell You an Item or Give You a Gift? [#94]

    October 29, 2021
    Can I Choose Guaranteed Saturday Delivery On Amazon-Walmart-UPS-etc (Updated Version)
    At Home & The Office

    Can I Choose Guaranteed Saturday Delivery On Amazon – Walmart – UPS – etc. ? (Updated Version) [#93]

    October 21, 2021
    Using Cash For Kapparos + Money Value of Chickens Used Kapara
    Shabbat and YomTov/Chol HaMoed

    Using Cash For Kapparos + Money Value of Chickens Used [#52]

    October 17, 2021
    Using A Mitzva Object Without Owners Permission – Example Case Of Shofar [#50]
    Stealing & Damages

    Using A Mitzva Object Without Owners Permission – Example Case Of Shofar [#50]

    October 17, 2021
    How To Pay & Do Teshuva For Money Matters (Private Person or Public) [#51]
    Stealing & Damages

    How To Pay & Do Teshuva For Money Matters (Private Person or Public) [#51]

    August 27, 2021
    Next Post
    stealing sleep

    Can You "Steal" Someone's Sleep By Waking Them Up? - Gezel Sheina [#86]

    Categories

    • At Home & The Office
    • Borrowing & Lending/ Laws of Interest (Ribbit)
    • Bosses & Employees/Workers – Business Partnerships
    • Buying/Shopping, Selling, & Making Money
    • new
    • Other Topics
    • Shabbat and YomTov/Chol HaMoed
    • Stealing & Damages
    • Tzedaka / Charity
    All Videos
    Can I Shop More When I'm Already Waiting In Line To Pay?
    Buying/Shopping, Selling, & Making Money

    Can I Shop More When I’m Already Waiting In Line To Pay? [#39]

    by Rabbi Binyamin Ghermezian
    January 19, 2022
    0

    Download Video Standard Quality Video HD Quality Video Listen/Download Audio

    Read more
    Can You Use A Switched Coat, Hat, or Similar Item?

    Can You Use A Switched Coat, Hat, or Similar Item? [#96]

    November 20, 2021
    How To Lend / Borrow Money Between Friends, Family, Or Strangers - Do I Need Witnesses Or A Signed Contract (Shtar)? [#95]

    How To Lend / Borrow Money Between Friends, Family, Or Strangers – Do I Need Witnesses Or A Signed Contract (Shtar)?

    November 14, 2021
    Can You Pressure Someone to Sell You an Item or Give You a Gift? [#94]

    Can You Pressure Someone to Sell You an Item or Give You a Gift? [#94]

    October 29, 2021
    Can I Choose Guaranteed Saturday Delivery On Amazon-Walmart-UPS-etc (Updated Version)

    Can I Choose Guaranteed Saturday Delivery On Amazon – Walmart – UPS – etc. ? (Updated Version) [#93]

    October 21, 2021

    Get Our Newest Content Delivered To Your Inbox

    Newsletter includes video and audio links as well as full text transcription of our latest videos. As an aid for those with internet filters, Google Drive/Dropbox links are also provided for accessing all current and previous video, audio, and text transcriptions

    Categories

    Categories

    • At Home & The Office
    • Borrowing & Lending/ Laws of Interest (Ribbit)
    • Bosses & Employees/Workers – Business Partnerships
    • Buying/Shopping, Selling, & Making Money
    • new
    • Other Topics
    • Shabbat and YomTov/Chol HaMoed
    • Stealing & Damages
    • Tzedaka / Charity

    Latest Videos

    Can I Shop More When I'm Already Waiting In Line To Pay?

    Can I Shop More When I’m Already Waiting In Line To Pay? [#39]

    Download Video Listen/Download Audio

    Can You Use A Switched Coat, Hat, or Similar Item?

    Can You Use A Switched Coat, Hat, or Similar Item? [#96]

    Can You Use A Switched

    How To Lend / Borrow Money Between Friends, Family, Or Strangers - Do I Need Witnesses Or A Signed Contract (Shtar)? [#95]

    How To Lend / Borrow Money Between Friends, Family, Or Strangers – Do I Need Witnesses Or A Signed Contract (Shtar)?

    How To Lend / Borrow

    Contact us

    Please Share

    CREATED BY DIGIKOR MEDIA WEB DESIGN COMPANY

    Social Networks
    SHARE ON FACEBOOK SHARE ON TWITTER SHARE ONGOOGLE PLUS SHARE ON LINKEDIN SHARE ON PINTEREST
    Share Link
    {{replacewithcurrurl}}
    Embed Code
    {{replacewithembedcode}}

    Add New Playlist

    Get videos via whatsapp

    Get Our Newest Videos + Text Via Email Newsletter

    Newsletter includes direct Google Drive & Dropbox links to accommodate those with internet filter